Shop OBEX P1 Docs P2 Docs Learn Events
underwater motors — Parallax Forums

underwater motors

ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
edited 2000-07-26 18:02 in General Discussion
There are some technologies used for sealing underwater motors;

Presssure sealed:
a) O 'ring shaft seals: low, cost, may be difficult to project and prone
to fail. Works well only in small angular speeds (small diameters shafts
or slow RPM) Low MTBF.
b) Mechanical seals: Commercially available, Medium cost.Medium Life.
Low pressures.
c) High end mechanical seals (Mag-Seal etc..) Two precision lapped
surfaces. High cost. Very reliable. Hard to find small diameters.
d) Two isolated shafts, magnetic coupling. High cost. Fail safe.

Pressure balanced:
a) Use oil ( low viscosity oil ) immersed motors. Use O'rings are used
only to avoid large oil escape or large water entrance. O'rings will
work at same pressure at both sides. Low cost.High MTBF. Oil helps to
heat exchange. This method is used in commercial deep sea thrusters.
Large RC Servo motors already are O'ring sealed. Enclosure oil filling
is best done with a vaccum pump.

Are you looking for these motors for a pan & tilt camera system or they
will be used for propulsion ?

ACJacques

Raphael Abrams wrote:
>
> anybody know of a source for inexpensive submarine motors? i'm making an
> underwater servo controlled camera for depths of 150 feet. if the motor
> can come in a sort of sealed off ducted fan arrangement, that would be
> ideal.
>
> thanks!
> raphael abrams

Comments

  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-24 19:34
    anybody know of a source for inexpensive submarine motors? i'm making an
    underwater servo controlled camera for depths of 150 feet. if the motor
    can come in a sort of sealed off ducted fan arrangement, that would be
    ideal.

    thanks!
    raphael abrams
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-24 19:51
    At 02:34 PM 7/24/00 -0400, Raphael wrote:
    >
    >anybody know of a source for inexpensive submarine motors? i'm making an
    >underwater servo controlled camera for depths of 150 feet. if the motor
    >can come in a sort of sealed off ducted fan arrangement, that would be
    >ideal.

    I don't know if this will be much help, but years ago I built a two-person
    wetsub for scuba use with motor heads from those electric outboard trolling
    motors. I seem to recall that we purchased a few of the motor head
    assemblies only, right from the manufacturer. These were powerful, cheap
    and ran forever from a deep cycle 12 volt battery. Our sub had four, and at
    high speed it would pull our masks off! We had to add a small 'windscreen'
    (hydroscreen?) to deflect some of the water pressure. A piece of thin
    aluminum tubing made a great duct, or I guess you could even use large
    diameter PVC. I don't know if the pressure seals would hold up at that
    depth. You could try contacting some of the companies that actually
    manufacture those trolling motors...

    Cheers, Duncan
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-25 13:10
    use trolling motors, they can be had from almost anywhere.

    Norm & Monda
    Cozy MK IV #202
    Ford V-6 Powered
    Original Message
    From: "Raphael Abrams" <raphael@w...>
    To: <basicstamps@egroups.com>
    Sent: Monday, July 24, 2000 2:34 PM
    Subject: [noparse][[/noparse]basicstamps] underwater motors


    >
    > anybody know of a source for inexpensive submarine motors? i'm making an
    > underwater servo controlled camera for depths of 150 feet. if the motor
    > can come in a sort of sealed off ducted fan arrangement, that would be
    > ideal.
    >
    > thanks!
    > raphael abrams
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-25 15:23
    Radio Shack has TOY motors on a model of a RC wave runner. But I would not
    trust them unless I had a
    fail safe way to retrive my camera. I am thinking of building a
    tethered camera using these motors to study Dragonfly larva
    in my pond. How did you seal the camera, Is it autonomous or tethered ?

    Raphael Abrams wrote:

    > anybody know of a source for inexpensive submarine motors? i'
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-25 16:54
    In a message dated 7/24/00 1:37:11 PM, raphael@w... writes:

    >anybody know of a source for inexpensive submarine motors? I'm making an
    >underwater servo controlled camera for depths of 150 feet. if the motor
    >can come in a sort of sealed off ducted fan arrangement, that would be
    >ideal.
    >
    two classic inexpensive ROV motor sources are small sealed bilge pumps for
    steering and control (Rule® or Johnson are available at places like WEST
    MARINE), or for more power, you can use trolling motors. I bought mine pretty
    cheap at a goodwill superstore.

    ===========
    Larry Geib

    ljgeib@a...
    ===========
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-25 16:55
    thanks all for the responses!


    a. c. jacques: initially i will need a propulsion motor, but i will
    eventually want a sewt of waterproof servos as well. I like the magnetic
    coupling idea, any sources?


    duncan, norm: trolling motors sound good, but where can i find a small
    one? this device only weighs about 3 or 4 pounds, and is neutral in water.

    do you know a couple of brand names i can try?


    maybe a motor from a toy
    submarine would work?

    thanks again to all,
    raphael abrams
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-25 18:37
    Magnetic coupling is not cheap. Concentric cylinder rings of rare earth
    magnetics with small diameter and the required torque for a thruster may
    cost more than a thousand $ ! (Giannini Petro-Marine - California )
    There are some pumps brands (??) that uses also magnetic couplings(low
    torque) but they are disks that will add axial attraction forces in the
    shaft.You may project and make yourself these disks with a number of
    small strong magnets.

    Bilge pumps and trolling motors are not designed to work in high
    differential pressures like underwater. Higher pressures, may stress,
    shorten life or completely fail the sealing components.

    The technique of pressure balanced( oil immersion ) could be easyly be
    implemented in a trolling motor giving you a very reliable thruster.
    You just need drill a hole in air compartment of armature rotor,and fill
    it with Singer machine oil or other low viscosity inert fluid ( kerosene
    ? )and fit a small lenght of flexible hose (silicone) that could be
    closed at the other end. Water pressure will compress the hose,
    equalizing the internal pressure . Eventual trapped air bubbles will be
    compressed lowering the total volume. The inside volume of hose must be
    higher than these bubbles.

    Electric trolling motors are available from fractional HP up to few.
    The cost may start from around $250 ea.
    Check web for Mini-Kota motors.
    There are also Johnson, and Mercury, and other outboard manufacturers
    that sell electric trollers.

    Good servos and strong RC servos (Tonegawa Seiko -SSPS) are avaiable
    from
    vantec.com


    ACJacques


    Raphael Abrams wrote:
    >
    > thanks all for the responses!
    >
    > a. c. jacques: initially i will need a propulsion motor, but i will
    > eventually want a sewt of waterproof servos as well. I like the magnetic
    > coupling idea, any sources?
    >
    > duncan, norm: trolling motors sound good, but where can i find a small
    > one? this device only weighs about 3 or 4 pounds, and is neutral in water.
    >
    > do you know a couple of brand names i can try?
    >
    > maybe a motor from a toy
    > submarine would work?
    >
    > thanks again to all,
    > raphael abrams
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-25 21:37
    >Just a thought on the submarine motor issue.
    >
    >Depending on your power requirements and budget, the market is full of very
    >inexpensive epoxy incapsulated submersible pumps. These could be homebrewed
    >into a cheap 'jet' engine or reaction thruster. They are available in a
    >full
    >range of power ratings and potential thrust capacities. Prices range from
    >$10-$60.

    ...and depending on the thrust you need to generate, you might be able to
    mount the pumps pointing perpendicular to the desired plane of travel, and
    use a duct to redirect the flow by 90 degrees. Rotating the duct gives you
    thrust in any direction along the plane the pump's output is perpendicular
    to.

    I've seen similar setups used for "docking thruster" type purposes, with the
    output jets pointing straight down from the hull, and using a rotating duct
    to redirect the thrust forwards, backwards, or to the sides -- sort of a
    parallel parking method for boats. It just pulled up to a few feet from the
    dock, rotated the ducts, and slid sideways up to it. Very clever
    arrangement, and worked like a charm.


    ________________________________________________________________________
    Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-26 03:51
    Just a thought on the submarine motor issue.

    Depending on your power requirements and budget, the market is full of very
    inexpensive epoxy incapsulated submersible pumps. These could be homebrewed
    into a cheap 'jet' engine or reaction thruster. They are available in a full
    range of power ratings and potential thrust capacities. Prices range from
    $10-$60.

    Regards



    ________________________________________________________________________
    Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-26 17:16
    thanks again for all the good information!



    to answer a few last questions: the camera is in a plexiglass box and the
    whole thing is tethered with five or six wires- power, ground, camera
    output, and serial in and out. there will be a pan tilt servo setup on the
    camera, and a bunch of power transistors (or maybe even relays, if I don't
    need speed control) and a stamp1 program burnt onto a pic for servo
    and motor control.

    the tether will go to a control board that houses another stamp and a set
    of controls, and a small monitor (radioshack tv or video camera with
    inputs for recording)

    so thanks again to all, and any more ideas will be much appreciated, f
    course!

    -raphael abrams
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-26 17:30
    Hi Raphael,
    I found this link to Minnkota, one of the major trolling
    motor manufacturers:

    MINNKOTA TROLLING MOTORS
    (800) 227-6433 MN
    http://www.jwa.com/motors/minnkota/minnkota.html

    Although it sounds like these will be too large/powerful for your app.
    I've been thinking about the pressure requirements of whatever seals you
    use and it shouldn't be too difficult to get a solid seal. At 150ft the
    pressure will be ~67 psi - seems well within the reach of even simple seals.

    Best, Duncan
  • ArchiverArchiver Posts: 46,084
    edited 2000-07-26 18:02
    How about a picture or a website linking to pictures of your system when it
    is finished? It sounds very interesting.

    Sincerely
    Kerry
    Admin@M...
    WWW server hosting
    [url=Http://mntnweb.com]Http://mntnweb.com[/url]
    Binghamton online Webcam [url=Http://MntnWeb.Com/bing.htm]Http://MntnWeb.Com/bing.htm[/url]
    CHRISTMAS Web Page [url=Http://mntnweb.com/xmas.htm]Http://mntnweb.com/xmas.htm[/url]
Sign In or Register to comment.