Shop OBEX P1 Docs P2 Docs Learn Events
Complete cycle-correct emulation of CPU with external bus — Parallax Forums

Complete cycle-correct emulation of CPU with external bus

Hi everyone!

It's been over 10 years since I did something with the Propeller. I just got tired waiting for Prop2, then life stuff kicked in, so I could not do any electronics at all. But I guess you cannot just throw away the Propeller passion :smile:

So I am thinking about a good project to learn the ins and outs of Prop2, and I have this idea of a CPU emulator that not only executes the instructions correctly, but also has a proper electrical bus with correct timing that would allow connecting external hardware. Possibly Z80, 6502 or 6800.

Anyone knows if such a project exists for P2?

Comments

  • No, does not exist yet. I have created 68000, Z80 and SPC700 cores, but those have instruction-level timing at best (or no timing at all for the 68000). Pratically all the peripherals you could realistically want for an 80s CPU can also be emulated inside the P2. But external bus emulation should be possible for the slower 8-bit CPUs.

  • pik33pik33 Posts: 2,387

    6502 emulator by macca, while not doing this as it is now, can be upgraded to do this as there is still a place in LUT RAM, a lot of time, and its structure allows such upgrade.

  • @pik33 said:
    6502 emulator by macca, while not doing this as it is now, can be upgraded to do this as there is still a place in LUT RAM, a lot of time, and its structure allows such upgrade.

    Thanks, I'll look into it

  • Andrey DemenevAndrey Demenev Posts: 377
    edited 2023-04-18 22:39

    While waiting for the propeller board to arrive, I am trying to outline the project and understand what I would need. So it looks like 6502 would be a good starting point, as it is least complicated in terms of both instructions and the bus. Well, there is BCD, but let's leave it for now :smile:

    To debug the electrical bus, I would need some means of analyzing what's going on there. Unfortunately, I am living out of my home now, finances are pretty limited, and I do not have access to an oscilloscope, and even obtaining electronic components is kinda troublesome. I was thinking about making some basic logic analyzer out of 74 logic which I can get here. The idea is to latch the bus state into registers, and then shift the bits out, receive them with a USB to serial converted and visualize on a computer. I think I could run the Prop at extremely low clock frequency, so the serial transmission rate is within usable range , and the bus state can be transmitted on each prop clock

  • jmgjmg Posts: 15,175
    edited 2023-04-19 01:17

    @"Andrey Demenev" said:
    To debug the electrical bus, I would need some means of analyzing what's going on there. Unfortunately, I am living out of my home now, finances are pretty limited, and I do not have access to an oscilloscope, and even obtaining electronic components is kinda troublesome. I was thinking about making some basic logic analyzer out of 74 logic which I can get here. The idea is to latch the bus state into registers, and then shift the bits out, receive them with a USB to serial converted and visualize on a computer. I think I could run the Prop at extremely low clock frequency, so the serial transmission rate is within usable range , and the bus state can be transmitted on each prop clock

    Depending on your budget, there are very low cost HS-USB parallel logic analysers like this
    https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32896748758.html
    or this, in a case
    https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005001417581550.html
    Those use a Cypress HS-USB parallel chip (or a clone) and sample at up to 24MHz, so you would not need to slow the Prop much ?
    and I find this
    https://community.infineon.com/t5/Knowledge-Base-Articles/Cypress-EZ-USB-FX2LP-based-Logic-Analyzer-using-Open-Source-sigrok-PulseView/ta-p/252866

    Sync to the Prop clock is a good idea, or vice versa.
    I find this
    https://sigrok.org/wiki/Lcsoft_Mini_Board
    that mentions a 24MHz xtal, so you could do a simple HW mod to add a 1GU04 / 2GU04 buffer to the CY7C68013A crystal, to get a buffered version you could feed into P2 XI, replacing the 20MHz xtal.
    That 'same clock' keeps the P2 and capture clocks phase locked, and some small loading (could even be the P2 Xtal Caps) adjust could nudge the phase a little, if you find sampling point issues.

  • @jmg said:
    Depending on your budget, there are very low cost HS-USB parallel logic analysers like this
    https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32896748758.html
    or this, in a case
    https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005001417581550.html
    Those use a Cypress HS-USB parallel chip (or a clone) and sample at up to 24MHz, so you would not need to slow the Prop much ?
    and I find this
    https://community.infineon.com/t5/Knowledge-Base-Articles/Cypress-EZ-USB-FX2LP-based-Logic-Analyzer-using-Open-Source-sigrok-PulseView/ta-p/252866

    Thanks. I tend to overcomplicate things :smile:

    I think I could use STM32 blue pill - it's fast and has enough pins

  • Speaking of STM and low speed I got one of those DSO138 units that worked ok.

    I now use a PropScope.

    Mike

  • It should probably be possible to use one cog of P2 to monitor the pins, I think!?!

  • Don't You want to tackle the 6809? A P2 coco3 emulator with OS9 would be the perfect match....
    I invested some time, but my porting attempt in C was too slow. https://forums.parallax.com/discussion/174794/towards-os9-operating-system-on-p2/p1

  • TonyB_TonyB_ Posts: 2,193
    edited 2023-04-19 14:31

    @"Andrey Demenev" said:
    While waiting for the propeller board to arrive, I am trying to outline the project and understand what I would need. So it looks like 6502 would be a good starting point, as it is least complicated in terms of both instructions and the bus. Well, there is BCD, but let's leave it for now :smile:

    To debug the electrical bus, I would need some means of analyzing what's going on there. Unfortunately, I am living out of my home now, finances are pretty limited, and I do not have access to an oscilloscope, and even obtaining electronic components is kinda troublesome. I was thinking about making some basic logic analyzer out of 74 logic which I can get here. The idea is to latch the bus state into registers, and then shift the bits out, receive them with a USB to serial converted and visualize on a computer. I think I could run the Prop at extremely low clock frequency, so the serial transmission rate is within usable range , and the bus state can be transmitted on each prop clock

    No need for any hardware. Visual 6502 is a transistor-level simulator that can run 6502 programs using URLs containing 6502 opcodes.

    Visual 6502
    http://www.visual6502.org/JSSim/

    Advanced version is more useful:
    http://www.visual6502.org/JSSim/expert.html

    Example URL:
    http://visual6502.org/JSSim/expert.html?graphics=f&loglevel=-1&steps=24&r=2303&a=2303&d=38b0fea9ffeae8&nmi0=6&logmore=cycle,ab,db,rw,Fetch,pc,Execute,State,nmi,D1x1
    copied from here:
    http://forum.6502.org/viewtopic.php?p=16141#p16141

    User help:
    https://web.archive.org/web/20200201082442/http://visual6502.org/wiki/index.php?title=JssimUserHelp

    Wiki:
    https://web.archive.org/web/20210115205040/http://visual6502.org/wiki/index.php?title=Special:AllPages

    Github:
    https://github.com/trebonian/visual6502

    Node names and numbers can be found in:
    https://github.com/trebonian/visual6502/blob/master/nodenames.js

    C port:
    https://github.com/mist64/perfect6502

  • @"Christof Eb." said:
    It should probably be possible to use one cog of P2 to monitor the pins, I think!?!

    Yes, that would be perfect. I am not sure yet if that can be done though

  • @TonyB_ said:

    No need for any hardware. Visual 6502 is a transistor-level simulator that can run 6502 programs using URLs containing 6502 opcodes.

    Visual 6502
    http://www.visual6502.org/JSSim/

    How is that going to aid in finding out what the propeller is outputting to the bus?

  • jmgjmg Posts: 15,175

    @"Andrey Demenev" said:

    @"Christof Eb." said:
    It should probably be possible to use one cog of P2 to monitor the pins, I think!?!

    Yes, that would be perfect. I am not sure yet if that can be done though

    It can be done, but comes with caveats.
    It consumes a COG and requires the P2 to be 'up and running'.
    It also imposes a CLK max, which becomes a conflict
    if we start at fastest UARTS that's roughly 1MBytes/sec so you can sample 1M/s, but you need 12M osc to send, so the sample and clk speeds cannot be the same.

    The HS-USB modules based on CY7C68013A etc are 24x faster than that.

  • @jmg said:
    It also imposes a CLK max, which becomes a conflict

    Yes, I was thinking about it. Obviously an additional cog is required, even maybe 2 - the other one for bus-attached memory emulation. The bus state can be sampled into a buffer, and at the end of each machine cycle the simulation cog would wait for a signal that is emitted when serial transmission is complete. Not exactly real time and comes with a cost of additional instruction per machine cycle, but can be enough at the early stages of development

Sign In or Register to comment.