Shop OBEX P1 Docs P2 Docs Learn Events
gaging interest: carbon fiber robot panels — Parallax Forums

gaging interest: carbon fiber robot panels

propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
edited 2013-08-24 09:28 in General Discussion
This can be moved to the robotics section if anybody feels it should. I thought it would get more interest here.

Everyday at work we throw away pre-preg carbon fiber. Depending on what parts we are cutting we can have around 50 square feet of waste. I got enough yesterday to make three 13.5" circles, 0.120" thick, 17 ply, ~60% fiber. I just saw those big circles in the trash and thought they would make a good robot base. But I can make more than ill ever use.

This is a stuctural clothe, it has yellow kevlar tracers woven into it to highlight the fiber angles. So it's not going to be as pretty as a car hood. I could do custom sizes, limited only by the size of our scrap and the size of my press. I do have a limited unlimited supply, production schedule and cutfiles produce varying sizes and amounts of scrap. I can also get unidirectional carbon, kevlar cloth, sandwiched kevlar cloth/uni, and e-glass.

Would this be something anybody would want to buy? And the 13.5" round panels, how much would you be willing to pay? The excess resin would need to be cut off, would a rough cut with the bandsaw be good? Or do i need to have them cut professionally? Straight cuts are easy, round cuts would be hard with my equipment. Kevlar would have to be laser cut, the sawblade turns it into fuzz, and the kevlar turns the blade into a butter knife.

Im having trouble attaching a pic with my phone, ill do it when i get home.

Comments

  • prof_brainoprof_braino Posts: 4,313
    edited 2013-08-23 08:25
    New stuff is always great. But expensive stuff doesn't get used until justified by a specific need.

    If you could figure a way to get lots of scrap out for folks to experiment.... one in one hundred will eventually find a real, profitable use for it. An that person will then order tons, and maybe even send business your way.

    So, get it to many folks cheap, and eventually get a few paying customers. If you can afford a large number of small loses before you score a few large gains, this is one way to go.

    PM me if you want to send a pile to a single address, I have the Chicago Robot Club and Workshop 88, these are collections of folks very likely to have an interest.

    My $0.02
  • ercoerco Posts: 20,259
    edited 2013-08-23 08:58
    It sure sounds cool. People love carbon fiber, but it can be difficult and dangerous to work with for beginners. Isn't the dust & fibers an inhalation risk and & skin irritant? Don't get kevlar fiber particles in your eyes...

    Probably most useful for weight-critical apps, flying bots & such. But your post did make me order this carbon fiber stick-on film, just for cool effect. Might have to jazz up a plywood robot chassis sometime. :)

    http://www.ebay.com/itm/3D-Twill-Weave-CARBON-FIBER-VINYL-12-x-50-Roll-BLACK-Wrap-Sheet-31cm-x-127cm-/200752805382?pt=Motors_Car_Truck_Parts_Accessories&hash=item2ebdccb606#ht_749wt_683
  • propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
    edited 2013-08-23 09:50
    Im not trying to make a large business. My employer throws this stuff away and i hate seeing it go to waste. And if i can make a few bucks on the side then great. My material costs will be zero, i only need to be paid to collect the scrap pieces, cut them to the requested size, lay them up, and run the press. Maybe charge a little more if somebody wants a panel with aligned fiber angles, less if it can be random.

    It probably is best to avoid inhaling the dust while cutting or machining. But, that is true for any material. And if you're not used to it it can make you want to scratch your skin off.
  • Beau SchwabeBeau Schwabe Posts: 6,568
    edited 2013-08-23 11:05
    Carbon fiber IS different from other materials..... When I was in prosthetics, we were required (state law) to wear a breathing mask, and use a special ventilated room to cut or grind the stuff. Same rules for fiber glass... I cant imagine Kevlar being much different than fiber glass.
  • LoopyBytelooseLoopyByteloose Posts: 12,537
    edited 2013-08-23 11:09
    I have used carbon fiber tubing in R/C airplane wings as stiffeners. The stuff is great.. strong and light. It is easy to work with.

    I am not sure that fiberglass is any great hazard, and carbon mixed with epoxy seems no greater. I am sure someone would greatly appreciate scraps for small, strong, tough, and light-weight devices. It is certainly easier to use that sheet metal.
  • PublisonPublison Posts: 12,366
    edited 2013-08-23 11:39
    While not a great hazard, a mask MUST be used when cutting fibreglass or carbon fiber. While neither are not considered a Carcinogen, they will do a number on you respiratory track.

    Just remember that very itchy feeling on your skin when laying fiberglass insulation. The lungs are very more susceptible to irritation from both products.
  • Beau SchwabeBeau Schwabe Posts: 6,568
    edited 2013-08-23 11:46
    It's the dust from cutting or grinding carbon fiber or fiberglass that can cause mechanical irritation in the eyes and lungs. Additionally long term exposure is accumulative since the body does not recognize it as being a foreign object and try to expel it through conventional biological methods.
  • prof_brainoprof_braino Posts: 4,313
    edited 2013-08-23 13:19
    propMaker wrote: »
    if you're not used to it it can make you want to scratch your skin off.
    ... required (state law) to wear a breathing mask, and use a special ventilated room to cut or grind the stuff.
    It's the dust from cutting or grinding carbon fiber or fiberglass that can cause mechanical irritation in the eyes and lungs. Additionally long term exposure is accumulative since the body does not recognize it as being a foreign object and try to expel it through conventional biological methods.

    I'm begining to like this stuff more and more! How do I get some?
  • Phil Pilgrim (PhiPi)Phil Pilgrim (PhiPi) Posts: 23,514
    edited 2013-08-23 13:54
    propMaker wrote:
    if you're not used to it it can make you want to scratch your skin off.
    My first job upon moving here was cutting, laminating, and grinding fiberglass at a boat-building plant. The constant itch -- especially at night when I was trying to sleep -- was almost unbearable. One thing I learned, though, was to take a cold shower after work. Hot showers only open the pores and drive the itch particles further into the skin. A cold shower has a chance, at least, of rinsing the stuff off.

    -Phil
  • PublisonPublison Posts: 12,366
    edited 2013-08-23 14:51
    My first job upon moving here was cutting, laminating, and grinding fiberglass at a boat-building plant. The constant itch -- especially at night when I was trying to sleep -- was almost unbearable. One thing I learned, though, was to take a cold shower after work. Hot showers only open the pores and drive the itch particles further into the skin. A cold shower has a chance, at least, of rinsing the stuff off.

    -Phil

    I learned the cold shower method also when building fiberglass hovercrafts. We also sprayed our arms with hair spray to seal the pores before work.
  • garyggaryg Posts: 420
    edited 2013-08-23 17:21
    Hi PropMaker and everyone else.

    It sounds like you would like to make some use of scrap PrePreg Carbon Fiber material.
    Have you any experience with building tooling for other parts made of the carbon?
    I'm currently involved in a personal project to build a bracket for housing dual lights and the original white reflector that
    is on All bicycles purchased in the United States.

    I'm inserting a photo of my current prototype carbon and aluminum tube bracket, still under construction

    IMG_1649 trimmed.jpg


    It's very interesting that you are working with Carbon Fibre in a production environment.
    I'll be using my bracket, still in the works, to mount dual lights and bicycle computer.
    Bicycles are not made to do this for some reason.

    Carbon Fibre is very light weight and could be used in very many bicycle projects.

    NOW

    Here is my point.
    What I'm seeing in my near future is a carbon fibre formed part that houses some LIPO batteries with a Solar cell charger
    so that I could connect my NiteRider MiNewt bicycle light.

    The solar charger could be voltage and or current regulated via microcontroller.

    I think I'm not alone in not having enough mounting space for accessories on bicycles.
    I also think that building simple mechanical things are somewhat difficult for most people starting in robotics and or
    other mechanical / Microcrontroller projects.

    Please keep your mind open to new ideas.
    While the Carbon Fibre topic may seem off topic, I'm guessing that people other than myself are very much appreciating this.

    Any and All comments to my Rantings are appreciated.

    GaryG
    1024 x 813 - 95K
  • propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
    edited 2013-08-23 18:12
    The safety guys at work don't seem concerned about fiber. It floats through the air, and collects into little black tumble weeds that roam the building.
  • NWCCTVNWCCTV Posts: 3,629
    edited 2013-08-23 18:17
    I could use some pieces of carbon fiber tubing if you have any of that availabe. Not sure if you have ever seen the Glow Sticks that electricians and cable runners use but I would need it about that size. If you can do tubing let me know and I will get the exact IDxOD dimensions and lengths needed.
  • propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
    edited 2013-08-23 18:38
    garyg wrote: »
    Hi PropMaker and everyone else.

    It sounds like you would like to make some use of scrap PrePreg Carbon Fiber material.
    Have you any experience with building tooling for other parts made of the carbon?
    I'm currently involved in a personal project to build a bracket for housing dual lights and the original white reflector that
    is on All bicycles purchased in the United States.

    I'm inserting a photo of my current prototype carbon and aluminum tube bracket, still under construction

    IMG_1649 trimmed.jpg


    It's very interesting that you are working with Carbon Fibre in a production environment.
    I'll be using my bracket, still in the works, to mount dual lights and bicycle computer.
    Bicycles are not made to do this for some reason.

    Carbon Fibre is very light weight and could be used in very many bicycle projects.

    NOW

    Here is my point.
    What I'm seeing in my near future is a carbon fibre formed part that houses some LIPO batteries with a Solar cell charger
    so that I could connect my NiteRider MiNewt bicycle light.

    The solar charger could be voltage and or current regulated via microcontroller.

    I think I'm not alone in not having enough mounting space for accessories on bicycles.
    I also think that building simple mechanical things are somewhat difficult for most people starting in robotics and or
    other mechanical / Microcrontroller projects.

    Please keep your mind open to new ideas.
    While the Carbon Fibre topic may seem off topic, I'm guessing that people other than myself are very much appreciating this.

    Any and All comments to my Rantings are appreciated.

    GaryG

    Your prototype looks great.

    As far as making molds, there is a guy that makes repair molds that I could learn from. He uses fiberglass, some other type of epoxy and aluminum pellets for filler. I'm not sure if a mold like that could handle 250° for curing this material. I will have to check the documentation to see what it can handle. The other problem is, the stuff he uses is, if I'm remembering correctly, over $100 per pint.

    For an enclosure like you're wanting, using dry fiber and laying it up in a mold with room temp curing resin would probably be best. I don't have experience doing that myself. But I think i could learn.

    My prices could be higher than it needs to be. Everything we use is aviation/aerospace grade material. I would like to get more into mold making and molding parts, I see fiber composites as a good future.
  • propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
    edited 2013-08-23 18:47
    NWCCTV wrote: »
    I could use some pieces of carbon fiber tubing if you have any of that availabe. Not sure if you have ever seen the Glow Sticks that electricians and cable runners use but I would need it about that size. If you can do tubing let me know and I will get the exact IDxOD dimensions and lengths needed.

    We have experimented with making tubing at work. It was a slow expensive process. It was about 2 to 2 1/2" OD, with 1/4" wall thickness. It was supposed to be used in landing gear but the customer said it cost too much for the weight savings. I forget the load we tested it at, but it could handle a 4 passenger plane dropping on this single strut.

    Tubing would require a special mold and carbon socks. We have the material, but we don't produce usable lengths of scrap.
  • NWCCTVNWCCTV Posts: 3,629
    edited 2013-08-23 19:04
    Tubing would require a special mold and carbon socks.
    Yes, I am aware of this. I have explored several options and for the application it would be used for the price is just too extreme. I just thought if you had any smaller tubing I would be interested. hanks for the reply.
  • propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
    edited 2013-08-23 20:13
    NWCCTV wrote: »
    Yes, I am aware of this. I have explored several options and for the application it would be used for the price is just too extreme. I just thought if you had any smaller tubing I would be interested. hanks for the reply.

    I had an idea for making tubes, that would require a smaller mold, but allow near infinite lengths to be molded. One layer would be easy, two or more would start complicating things. I tried to get management to listen to my idea, but nobody seemed interested. I should look into how it's made now, it could be in use already for all I know.
  • garyggaryg Posts: 420
    edited 2013-08-23 20:15
    Hi again
    I've made some tubes out of Fiberglass Cloth, 6oz / epoxy.
    If a special mandrel is not used, it's difficult to remove from the tool,
    especially if the diameter of the tube is small.
    I've been thinking lately that wraping a piece of tubing with paper and laminating the Carbon Fibre over top might be the answer.

    PropMaker,
    As far as my fiberglass/carbon projects have been concerned, If you can possibly make a tool out of Plaster of Paris and bake it
    at about 100 degreesF for about 48 hrs., the moisture of the plaster is gone and it will handle over 500 degrees temperature.
    That would be plenty of heat handling in an autoclave oven, as long as all the moisture is removed.
    It might pay for you to try some Plaster of Paris experiments.

    My thoughts about health safety and Carbon Fibre are concerned:
    My basement workshop was originally set up to make furniture out of Black Walnut.
    I use HEPA filters on my dust removal equipment because I found out that wood dust from Black Walnut and other species
    has been determined to be a cancer causing material.

    I would imagine that if Anyone is working in an environment that has dust needs to use every precaution available to eliminate the
    particulate from getting in their lungs.

    When I'm trimming fiberglass or Carbon fiber, I always do the 1st crude trimming outside with a grinder or saw with the wind at my back.
    My sanding equipment uses HEPA filters, but I do only minimal finish sanding in my basement workshop.

    AND

    A question from the original message on this thread.
    How heavy are the 1/8" x 13.5" diameter circles, LBS or GRAMS.
    For small robotics projects, I'm thinking that 13.5" circles about 0.040 thick would be more than strong enough.

    Another AND,
    When bonding one aged Carbon Fibre part to another, What is the best way to prepare the parts to be bonded.
  • propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
    edited 2013-08-23 20:22
    garyg wrote: »
    How heavy are the 1/8" x 13.5" diameter circles, LBS or GRAMS.
    For small robotics projects, I'm thinking that 13.5" circles about 0.040 thick would be more than strong enough.

    Another AND,
    When bonding one aged Carbon Fibre part to another, What is the best way to prepare the parts to be bonded.

    I weighed one, but forgot to write it down. With the excess resin still attached I think it was right around a pound. I will weigh it again Monday. I make some panels for quality testing that are 0.040". They are pretty flexible and springy. I also make some that are 0.080" and they are rigid. I chose 0.120 because I have the shims for it and I thought it would be thick enough to drill and tap. If 0.080 is thick enough then I could increase my yield by 50%.

    I glue fiberglass pieces to carbon for one test. I rough up the surfaces of both with around 200 grit sand paper. I usually just blow the dust off with compressed air. It can also be wiped with a rag soaked in acetone. I mix the epoxy up and add glass micro-balloons. The balloons prevent the two parts from squeezing all of the adhesive out. Fiberglass cloth can also be used to space the pieces apart. This bond is a little over 1 square inch on both sides and holds more than 6,000 lbs in shear, that's when the carbon breaks.
  • propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
    edited 2013-08-23 20:48
    Here are the pictures I promised.
    carbonCircle.jpg
    carbonWeave.jpg
    1024 x 612 - 69K
    1024 x 612 - 115K
  • Phil Pilgrim (PhiPi)Phil Pilgrim (PhiPi) Posts: 23,514
    edited 2013-08-23 21:45
    I might actually have been interested in the material if I thought my laser cutter could cut it. But I tried that once; it barely made a mark on the surface! Perhaps it's because the carbon carried the heat away so quickly; I'm just not sure why.

    -Phil
  • propMakerpropMaker Posts: 65
    edited 2013-08-24 07:10
    I might actually have been interested in the material if I thought my laser cutter could cut it. But I tried that once; it barely made a mark on the surface! Perhaps it's because the carbon carried the heat away so quickly; I'm just not sure why.

    -Phil

    I never thought composites were good heat conductors. I ruined some fiberglass parts with the heat from a few strain gages. Though part of that was from powering them with 30V instead of 10V, oops. We had some carbon laser cut and it didn't turn out good. The edges of the cut was very weak from burning and the heat.

    I think a water jet would work good.
  • LoopyBytelooseLoopyByteloose Posts: 12,537
    edited 2013-08-24 09:28
    My first job upon moving here was cutting, laminating, and grinding fiberglass at a boat-building plant. The constant itch -- especially at night when I was trying to sleep -- was almost unbearable. One thing I learned, though, was to take a cold shower after work. Hot showers only open the pores and drive the itch particles further into the skin. A cold shower has a chance, at least, of rinsing the stuff off.

    -Phil

    Have you ever heard of 'barrier cream'?

    http://www.ecfibreglasssupplies.co.uk/c-603-personal-protection.aspx

    And now there seems to be "after work cream".

    If one dreads breathing any dust at all, stay away. But I have quite a bit of exposure to fiberglass, sawdust and sheet rock dust. I seem to be okay. Precautions are wise, but that doesn't mean that this stuff is a huge hazard.
Sign In or Register to comment.