CNC - The New Plan... Any Feedback?

2»

Comments

  • MicksterMickster Posts: 981
    edited March 15 Vote Up0Vote Down
    idbruce wrote: »
    Mickster

    That Simblee device looks very interesting and promising, and I am going to take a serious look into it. What about indoor range, like in a multi-story concrete building? If everyone had Andriods and were at various locations in the structure, would there be any connectivity problems?

    I forget the details but the range is programmable. I want to get one but I know that it will only distract me... :-D
    PropBASIC ROCKS!
  • Ah, found it...

    Glad you found it. Because I wanted to see it again :) Exceptional craftsmanship


    Novel Solutions - http://www.novelsolutionsonline.com/ - Machinery Design • - • Product Development
    "Necessity is the mother of invention." - Author unknown.

  • idbruce wrote: »
    Ah, found it...

    Glad you found it. Because I wanted to see it again :) Exceptional craftsmanship

    The front end is what people see and interact with every day and it's all about perception. This is where you don't want to skimp which is why the user interface is so important. People are accustomed to high quality/resolution displays, today and anything less will be perceived as yesterday's thing.

    PropBASIC ROCKS!
  • You might consider the ShapeOKO3 controller board for your desk top plotter / CNC machining. It has a USB port, GRBL firmware, and 4 (24 VDC) stepper driver circuits all built-in and ready to go. I have their table top CNC, open source, machine and this controller is very solid and very reliable. Controller board price is $135
    The link is HERE https://shop.carbide3d.com/products/carbide-motion-pcb?variant=16688468102

  • Christof Eb.Christof Eb. Posts: 292
    edited March 18 Vote Up0Vote Down
    Hi Bruce,
    some comment, perhaps helpful?
    I totally agree, that it makes a lot of sense to reuse hardware and software. Some years ago I invested a lot of time to convert a small lathe into cnc. It was based on a notebook with DOS. After several years it broke down and I wondered how to replace it. Finally (after trying Sphinx for example), I came to the following solution. The idea is to cut the control into layers.

    Raspi 2
    Use Internet, file Server Access, useful programms like Editor
    DosBox
    utilities from the DOS-machine with output in HPGL
    python program that can read some subset of HPGL, display graphics of the CNC-code and send commands to a Propeller board
    Propeller Controller Board
    Runs Tachyon Forth
    rather simple very Basic machine control, just linear movements

    Why use Propeller at the hardware frontend side? - powerful Multitasking easily possible. Flexible, additional Hardware can easily be added.
    Why use forth? - It already has a protocol built in: You send a command via seral line and it will do something. It can easily give answers. Fast. Multitasking.
    Why use HPGL? It is very simple compared to G-code. Some graphics programms can directly output HPGL.
    Why use a small Linux System? Full blown file system and so on. Powerful, cheap, a lot of RAM. For an upgrade I would use odroid C2. But it would be possible to use a Windows notebook here.

    An arduino will be at it's very limit, so changements will be difficult. You have to be completely sure, that the code fully supports your Needs, because it is difficult to modify it.
    Best regards, Christof
  • Jason
    I've looked at it before, and it's not trivial code. In order to make it work, and fast enough, they're essentially multi-tasking with interrupts. They use interrupts to drive the motor pulses, and there's a lot of hardware specific code in there for doing things like adjusting the timing of interrupts dynamically, setting specific pin/port masks, and so on.

    The higher level code could likely be ported fairly trivially, but the low level bits are ugly and would require a fairly solid understanding of what they do on the Arduino hardware in order to port to the Prop.

    I did not go over it too thoroughly, but at first glance, it appears that most of the ugly code is contained and limited to "stepper.c". However, I am sure that you probably spent more time looking at it than I did.

    It looks easier to understand than Teacup did, but then again, I just took a cursory look.


    Novel Solutions - http://www.novelsolutionsonline.com/ - Machinery Design • - • Product Development
    "Necessity is the mother of invention." - Author unknown.

Sign In or Register to comment.